Prepare yoursef, this "before" photo is bit scary...

So, right off the bat, these bases are ah-mazing! The plaid shades however (which have been loosely constructed with yarn), not so much.
I'm planning to reconstruct the shades and recover them with a simple, bone white fabric to match the white of the bases. This will let the fantastic red, drip glaze take centre stage.
My question... Is the scale of the shades working for you?
I'm torn. Some days I feel like they're way too tall for the lamp. Other days, I love that about them.
What do you think? Should I trim down the shades to a more proportional scale, or does the fact that they're huge make the lamps that much more interesting?